Creemee Pie

Enjoy our delicious creemees, now in a 9-inch decorated creemee pie to enjoy at home! Select your creemee flavor(s) to be stacked, crust type, decoration style, and sprinkles for the top. The pie is frosted with a vanilla whipped topping.


Available Flavors:


Ginger  (Pick-up 4/4 - 4/10 only)

Black Raspberry  (Pick-up 4/4 - 4/10 only)

Butterscotch  (Pick-up 4/11 - 4/17 only)

Red Raspberry  (Pick-up 4/11 - 4/17 only)

Strawberry  (Pick-up 4/18 - 4/24 only)

Chocolate  (Pick-up 4/18 - 4/24 only)

Must be ordered 3+ days in advance.

Questions? Call us!  802-899-8199

To enjoy: Remove your pie from the freezer 10 to 20 minutes before serving. Heat the blade of a large knife by soaking in hot water and wipe off the excess. Then cut the pie into slices and enjoy! 


How to store: Store in the freezer like you would regular ice cream! If the creemee part of the pie will be exposed for an extended number of days, cover pie with saran wrap.  


Q: What allergens are in the pie? 

A: The pies contain dairy, wheat, and soy. All ingredients are nut free. If you are concerned about a certain allergen, please call our store with questions.


Q: Can I order one for pick-up in a few weeks?

A: Yes! We will take an order for pick-up within 14 days. If you need to order further ahead, call our store. 


Q: How far ahead do I need to order? What if I need it sooner?

A: All pie orders must be placed three days in advance. Any order needing to be picked up earlier than that is subject to a $10 rush fee. 


Q: Can I get a personalization or decoration on top?

A: YES! Select the Custom Creemee Pie online and put in your customization. There is a 25 character maximum.